realestate

Cayuga County: Top 9 Highest‑Priced Home Sales, Oct 25‑31

Cato home sold for $462k, leading Cayuga County's most expensive residential sales this week.

D
uring the week ending Oct. 31, Cayuga County logged 11 residential sales, averaging $226,573 per transaction and $201 per square foot. The highest‑priced property was a 4‑bed, 1‑bath house on Egypt Road in Cato, sold for $462,000 (built 1875, 2,201 sq ft).

    **Other notable sales**

    - **6170 W. Lake Road, Fleming** – $400,000; 3 bed, 1 bath; 1,397 sq ft; built 1931; $286/sq ft; closed Oct. 3.

    - **6198 Lake St., Aurelius** – $370,000; 4 bed, 3 bath; 2,201 sq ft; built 1840; $168/sq ft; closed Oct. 3.

    - **6487 State Route 90 N, Aurelius** – $305,000; 2 bed, 1 bath; built 1990; closed Oct. 6.

    - **5891 Bonnie Lynn Terrace, Fleming** – $281,000; 2 bed, 1 bath; 1,248 sq ft; built 1955; $225/sq ft; closed Oct. 3.

    - **27 Hamilton Ave., Auburn** – $194,000; 3 bed, 1 bath; 1,021 sq ft; built 1900; $190/sq ft; closed Oct. 7.

    - **24 Wood St., Auburn** – $164,300; 4 bed, 1 bath; 1,636 sq ft; built 1860; $100/sq ft; closed Oct. 6.

    - **516 Avery St., Sterling** – $162,000; 3 bed, 1 bath; 1,104 sq ft; built 1850; $147/sq ft; closed Oct. 3.

    - **9618 Stickles Lane, Conquest** – $10,000; built 1967; closed Oct. 7.

    - **10238 Egypt Road, Cato** – $462,000; 4 bed, 1 bath; built 1875; closed Oct. 6.

    Cayuga’s market shows a mix of historic and newer homes, with prices ranging from $10,000 to $462,000. The average price per square foot ($201) reflects the county’s diverse inventory, from modest 1,104‑sq‑ft homes to expansive 2,201‑sq‑ft estates.

    Other counties reported similar activity: Oneida and Tompkins each listed their top ten sales for the same week.

    **House of the Week** – A renovated Syracuse townhouse offers modern amenities and prime location.

    **County price trends** – Three Onondaga towns experienced a decline in home values this year.

    **Regional sales recap** – Seven Central NY counties’ transactions from Oct. 18‑24 are summarized for comparison.

    By accessing this site, you agree to our User Agreement and Privacy Policy, acknowledging that your interactions may be recorded and shared with third‑party partners.

Chart of Cayuga County's top nine highest‑priced home sales, Oct 25‑31.