realestate

Real Estate Transfers – Shelter Island Reporter, Dec 22, 2025

Listings for Times Review Media Group, by Suffolk Vision Inc., Oct 10 & 17 2025.

(
Credit: Reporter file)

    Listings for Times Review Media Group by Suffolk Vision Inc., Oct. 10 & 17, 2025.

    **SHELTER ISLAND Heights (11965)**

    - Hulse Trust → Cindy Treska & Daniel Poulter, 5 Bay Shore Dr., 700‑22‑1‑11 (R) $2.5 M

    **CUTCHOGUE (11935)**

    - Sandra Simchick → Andrew Oppenheimer & Nicole Dobranski, 1400 Track Ave., 1000‑137‑2‑3 (R) $889 k

    **GREENPORT (11944)**

    - Jagel Family Trust → 1820 Bay Shore LLC, 1820 Bay Shore Rd., 1000‑53‑4‑29 (R) $999 k

    - Meghan McDermott → Luis & Kris Pelaez, 215 Bridge St., 1001‑2‑2‑10.002 (R) $675 k

    - Enrico Del Favero & Katie Wiebicke → Enrico Favero, 1480 Cedarfields Dr., 1000‑40‑5‑1.036 (R) $240 k

    - William Saurer → Judith McCarthy, 10 Stirling Cove, 1001‑3.01‑1‑10 (R) $1.25 M

    - Erika Munter & Benjamin Weiss → Kenneth & Pauline Marulli, 10 Calebs Way, 1000‑40.01‑1‑10 (R) $595 k

    **JAMESPORT (11947)**

    - Lorraine & Robert Link → James & Nicole Gibson, 28 Center St., 600‑89‑1‑39 (R) $825 k

    **MATTITUCK (11952)**

    - Darren Hinderliter → Sarah Park, 745 Cottage Way, 1000‑122‑2‑23.007 (R) $258 k

    **NEW SUFFOLK (11956)**

    - Puric Family Trust → 1250 Second St LLC, 1250 Second St., 1000‑117‑7‑23 (R) $1.05 M

    **RIVERHEAD (11901)**

    - Emily Sills Trust → Stephen & Courtney Giovanniello, 309 Church Ln., 600‑46‑1‑15 (R) $625 k

    - Christopher & Kathleen Schroeher → 120 Duryea St Corp, 120 Duryea St., 600‑107‑1‑29.001 (R) $610 k

    - Estate of Nannie Smith → Allan Zilnicki & Thomas Dannenberg, 48 Zdunko Ln., 600‑42‑1‑11 (R) $540 k

    - Laurel Beniamino → Stephen & Karen Losi, 2804 Bayberry Path, 600‑18.01‑2‑176 (R) $507.5 k

    - 119 Sweezy Ave LLC → River City Capital LLC, 119 Sweezy Ave., 600‑128‑2‑2 (R) $490 k

    - We Buy Homes On LI LLC → KED Home LLC, 30 Millbrook Ln., 600‑131‑1‑5.001 (R) $575 k

    **SOUTHOLD (11971)**

    - Susan Meigs & Todd Vunderink → Thomas & Cynthia Murray, 50605 Route 25, 1000‑70‑1‑8 (R) $810 k

    - Robert Ballenger → Rita Kavanagh & John Nolan, 465 Tarpon Dr., 1000‑53‑5‑5 (R) $762.5 k

    - Estate of Stephen Blum → Jorge Rivas & Evelia Sanchez, 950 Main Bayview Rd., 1000‑70‑7‑17 (R) $740 k

    **Key**: Tax map numbers = District‑Section‑Block‑Lot; (A) agriculture; (R) residential; (V) vacant; (C) commercial; (R&E) recreation & entertainment; (CS) community services; (I) industrial; (PS) public service; (P) park land; values from current tax rolls.

New homeowners sign real estate transfer on Shelter Island property.