A
lexandra Andorfer and George Croton's love for San Francisco endured despite nearly a decade as renters in the city. They maximized their 950 square feet, even expanding their family to include two dogs and two cats in their cozy two-bedroom home near Buena Vista Park. However, frequent weekend getaways to Sonoma Valley, about 50 miles north, sparked an idea: could they trade urban life for a small-town setting that still offered the amenities they cherished?

    Growing up in big cities had shaped Ms. Andorfer's perspective, but Mr. Croton's upbringing in Santa Barbara, California, with its relaxed atmosphere and abundance of outdoor activities, made him more open to leaving San Francisco. Both attorneys could telecommute several days a week, allowing them to imagine an alternative lifestyle. Ms. Andorfer was particularly drawn to Sonoma, a foodie haven with 11,000 residents in the heart of wine country.

    "I quickly saw myself living there," she said. "It doesn't have city vibes, but it has culture and restaurants – lots going on." The couple began visiting open houses in Sonoma and Marin County, seeking an airy home with distinctive architecture within walking distance to shops and services. With a budget of $1.35 million and some help from Mr. Croton's mother for a down payment, they scouted properties for weeks.

    Their search led them to various options, including a 1,915-square-foot house in Sonoma that boasted three bedrooms, an open-plan living area, and vaulted ceilings. The home needed some upgrades, but its wraparound deck offered stunning views of the valley. With estimated annual taxes of $9,500, it was listed for $995,000 – within their budget.