realestate

Shelter Island Property Sales: 15 Nov 2025

Prepared by Times Review Group by Suffolk Vision Inc., Sept 5, 2025. Shelter Island – (R) $1.75M; Aquebogue – Beach Road

(
Credit: Reporter file)

    Listings for Times Review Media Group, Suffolk Vision Inc., Sept 5 2025.

    SHELTER ISLAND (11965) – 8TT → Stephen & Kelsey Heiner, 8 Tims Trail (700‑17‑2‑66) (R) $1,750,000

    AQUEBOGUE (11931) – 55 Beach Road → Todd D’Andrea & Andrea DeVitto, 55 Beach Rd (600‑113‑2‑38) (R) $640,000

    CUTCHOGUE (11935) – Lighthouse Point → Jake & Amy Dell, 9975 Nassau Point Rd (1000‑119‑1‑10.001) (R) $3,175,000

    EAST MARION (11939) – Cathryn Pallone → Victoria Kuhne & Paul Widdowson, 2820 Shipyard Ln Unit 1C1 (1000‑38.02‑1‑5) (R) $580,000

    GREENPORT (11944) – Melissa & Jason Harris → Delwin Olivan & Lin Yuan, 155 Caiola Ct (1000‑33‑3‑19.016) (R) $1,885,000

    RIVERHEAD (11901) – Riverhead Dodge → New Generation Properties, 642 W Main St (600‑124‑3‑18) (V) $2,500,000

    – Norma DeTolla Trust → David & Alice Luckman, 64 Wake Robin Ln (600‑20‑7‑3) (R) $865,000

    – Arthur & Michele Davis Trust → Angela & Mahmoud Moshfeghi, 3804 Amen Corner (600‑64.02‑1‑64) (R) $530,000

    – Linda Buckley → Pamela Stark, 2304 Augusta Alley (600‑64.01‑1‑40.001) (R) $479,500

    – Estate John Zlatniski → GMS East Main, 800 E Main St (600‑127‑5‑26) (C) $450,000

    – Janet Hoey → 2025 American Holdings, 44 Hubbard Ave (600‑111‑1‑6) (R) $260,000

    SOUTHOLD (11971) – Mary Duffy → Theresa Grimmig & Joseph Burga, 150 Mount Beulah Ave (1000‑51‑3‑2.004) (R) $1,395,000

    – Estate Gertrude Gaetjens → Charles Gaetjens, 14230 Soundview Ave (1000‑54‑3‑1) (R) $500,000

    Key: Tax map = District‑Section‑Block‑Lot; (A) agriculture; (R) residential; (V) vacant; (C) commercial; (R&E) recreation & entertainment; (CS) community services; (I) industrial; (PS) public service; (P) park land; values from current tax rolls.

Shelter Island property listings, November 15, 2025.