realestate

Shelter Island Property Transactions: May 2025 Update

Suffolk County Property Transfers Prepared by Suffolk Vision Inc., Feb. 21, 2025

H
ere is the rewritten text, condensed by 20%:

    Listings prepared for Times Review Media Group by Suffolk Vision Inc., dated February 21, 2025.

    SHELTER ISLAND (11964)

    • Stephen & Karen Ferrara sold to 3 South Cart LLC, 3 South Cartwright Road ($710,000)

    CUTCHOGUE (11935)

    • North Fork Storage LLC sold to Prime Storage North Fork LLC, 115 Commerce Drive ($19,000,000)

    • Jose Pirir sold to Lisa & Winfried Edelmann, 55 Pinewood Road ($1,450,000)

    • Mark Kreider sold to Samuel Pastrick & Megan Dropela, 570 Pequash Avenue ($899,000)

    EAST MARION (11939)

    • Estate of Agnes Reynolds sold to John & Maria Tsavalos, 4670 The Long Way ($905,000)

    FISHERS ISLAND (06390)

    • Estate of Donald Cleveland sold to Thomas Cleveland, 1305 Winthrop Drive ($900,000)

    GREENPORT (11944)

    • Estate of Brian Sinclair sold to Jonathan DiVello, 285 Park Street ($820,000)

    LAUREL (11948)

    • Aydinian Family Trust sold to Brooke Epperson & Gregory White, 1350 Aldrich Lane ($759,000)

    MATTITUCK (11952)

    • Peter R McGreevy and Estate of Michael Neudeck sold to Dalton Studios LLC, 1975 Cox Neck Road ($530,000)

    • Douglas Massey and Jennifer Hatfield sold to 14065 Main Road LLC, 14065 Main Road ($500,000)

    SOUTH JAMESPORT (11970)

    • Peter & Meggan Berley sold to James & Holly Skon, 127 Green Street ($910,000)

    SOUTHOLD (11971)

    • Elaine O’Connell sold to Philip & Joyce Sharfstein, 1205 Waterview Drive ($1,600,000)

Shelter Island real estate transactions, May 2025 update with property listings and sales data.