realestate

Upstate Private Island Retreat Seeks New Owners After Decades of Family Ownership

A humble fishing cabin evolved into a modern, 2,964 sq ft home with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and an abundance of cedar features.

A
lexander Nicolas's childhood was spent on St. Mary's Island, a tiny speck in the Thousand Islands region of northern New York. His parents bought the .3-acre islet 40 years ago for a modest fishing cabin, which they transformed into a stunning custom home over five years. The result was a 2,964-square-foot, three-bedroom retreat with cedar touches throughout.

    Nicolas's parents designed the property themselves, drawing inspiration from their love of natural wood and abstract art. They prioritized massive loft spaces, a wraparound porch, and light-filled interiors. But what sets this island home apart is its daring location on the water's edge, where a hydraulic dam controls the river's height and a garden flourishes.

    The property has been listed for $1.5 million with Mike Fabbri and Joshua Garner of the Agency. Nicolas says his parents' vision was to create a magical place that would enrich their family's childhood memories. The home's design is a nod to the region's rich history, including the nearby Boldt Castle, built by George Boldt for his wife in the early 20th century.

    The island itself has a small footbridge connecting it to Manhattan Island and offers stunning views of the surrounding waters. While owning this property comes with a price tag, Nicolas believes it's worth it for those who want to experience the simplicity and beauty of nature. As he puts it, "It's kind of magical."

Private island retreat in upstate New York seeks new owners after family sale.