C
arrie Underwood’s journey from a modest Oklahoma upbringing to a multi‑Grammy superstar has been mirrored in her real‑estate choices, which remain rooted in her Southern heritage. After winning *American Idol* in 2005, the country icon bought a 3,000‑sq‑ft home in Franklin, Tennessee, for $384,000. The stucco‑stone house, built in 1998, had three bedrooms, three and a half baths, and a library. She listed it again in 2011 for $419,900 but sold it in 2013 for $372,500, taking a small loss.
In 2007, Underwood expanded her portfolio with a $1.35 million Italian‑style villa in Brentwood, a gated golf community near Nashville. The four‑bedroom, six‑bath residence covered roughly 7,000 sq ft on a half‑acre lot. Its grand foyer featured marble floors, a crystal chandelier, and a winding staircase. The home boasted multiple fireplaces, wet bars, a detailed wood‑cabinet kitchen, and a basement glam room accessed via a spiral staircase in the master bathroom. A fall in 2017—she tripped while walking her dogs—led to 40‑50 stitches on her face and wrist surgery. The incident, coupled with neighborhood tensions, prompted the couple to sell the property in March 2019 for $1.41 million after listing it for $1.45 million.
The same year she married former Canadian hockey player Mike Fisher, the pair purchased an 11‑acre wooded estate in Ottawa. The gated house featured five bedrooms, five baths, a double‑sided fireplace, and a spacious kitchen. The basement offered a pool table, wet bar, gym, wine cellar, and a movie‑theater area. Outdoor amenities included a fire‑pit patio and a hot‑tub deck. The property sat near Fisher’s former rink with the Ottawa Senators and was sold in 2014 for an undisclosed price, roughly $2 million.
In 2011, Underwood and Fisher invested $3.2 million in a 400‑acre farm in Franklin, Tennessee, where they built a custom home that became their primary residence. The house incorporates a wood‑burning fireplace, porch swing, and rocking chairs—key elements the singer highlighted in a 2016 interview. The interior showcases a black‑and‑white kitchen with exposed beams, a rustic stone backsplash, a large island, and a walk‑in closet with washer and dryer. The property also includes horse stables, riding arenas, a greenhouse, a chicken coop, a sheep barn, vegetable gardens, and an orchard. Underwood often shares photos of her garden on Instagram, describing it as a place for reflection. The farm has been home to their two sons, Isaiah (born 2015) and Jacob (born 2019).
During the summer of 2021, Underwood rented the Hamptons estate known as Eagle’s Point in Water Mill, New York. The seven‑acre compound contains two homes totaling 8,500 sq ft, nine bedrooms, and eight baths. Features include a domed living room with yellow stained‑glass, an all‑white kitchen, a formal dining room with French doors opening onto a patio, multiple fireplaces, a home theater, a wine cellar, a tennis court, and an 81‑foot saltwater infinity pool that cost over $1 million to build. The hilltop location offers panoramic ocean views. The property was later rented by Mariah Carey and listed for $275,000 per month, though plans to replace it with a $50 million mansion have not materialized.
