Language
DEEN
Market analysis··2 min read

Market expertise: When specialist knowledge becomes sound judgement

Robert Knakal analyses the importance of judgement and market experience in commercial real estate transactions in New York City in the age of data and AI.

AI generatedMarket expertise: When specialist knowledge becomes sound judgement – AI-generated illustrative image
Market expertise: When specialist knowledge becomes sound judgement. Illustrative image generated using artificial intelligence (AI). The image does not depict a real property, person or event and is not a documentary photograph. Labelled in accordance with Article 50(4) of the EU AI Act.

Robert Knakal, active in the New York City investment market since 16 July 1984, has overseen the sale of more than 2,428 buildings with a total volume exceeding $25 billion over his 42-year career. From this practice, he derives fundamental principles for success in the commercial real estate business: while pure experience forms the raw material, it is only through discipline and curiosity that genuine expertise emerges, extending far beyond the mere retrieval of market data.

The distinction between facts and market understanding

While specialist knowledge merely describes familiarity with facts, expertise represents grasping their deeper context. Crucial judgement ultimately lies in knowing what actions should be derived from them. In Knakal's observation, two advisers assessing the same development site are often guided by identical baseline data: both examine zoning plans, comparable transactions, construction costs and financing assumptions. Nonetheless, they occasionally arrive at entirely different valuations, as purely mathematical models do not necessarily capture qualitative nuances such as construction challenges or shifting buyer preferences.

These insights, which cannot be found in spreadsheets, result from years of market observation, negotiations and direct contact with industry stakeholders. At BKREA, such empirical values feed into proprietary analytical tools:

  • —Knakal Map Room for visualising development activity, ownership structures and zoning potential
  • —Knakal Land Index for analysing historical transactions of development sites and price correlations
  • —Developer Ranking System for systematically recording market participants and their activity profiles

Data availability and the value of human judgement

Knakal emphasises that whilst such databases offer substantial informational advantages, their true benefit emerges only in conjunction with human judgement. An algorithm is capable of identifying patterns; however, professional interpretation and its concrete relevance to investment decisions require individual market knowledge. Technology and specialist expertise are therefore not interchangeable.

With the advance of artificial intelligence, this transformation is accelerating. AI systems can analyse extensive datasets, summarise documents and generate financial models in a matter of moments. In Knakal's view, this reduces the relative value of mere access to information, whilst the quality of interpretation and strategic decision-making gains weight. Another essential hallmark of genuine expertise remains the willingness to recognise clearly one's own limitations.

Looking for
a real estate
agent?

Michael Freitag — founder of FREITAG® Immobilien
Michael Freitag
Founder of FREITAG® Immobilien GmbH
More than 15 years of experience in Bavaria & surroundings
— FREITAG Immobilien

Your discreet partner for institutional transactions in German-speaking Europe.

As a premium real estate firm based in Munich we advise investors, family offices, developers and long-term holders on the acquisition, sale and valuation of residential, income and commercial properties — confidential, close to the market and on equal terms.

3.600+
municipalities on our market radar
48 h
first assessment of your property
Off-market
discreet circle of buyers
DACH
DE · AT · CH
— Confidential contact

Let us talk about your portfolio.

Acquisition profiles, off-market opportunities, valuations or development enquiries — we reply personally within 24 hours, NDA as a matter of course.

Phone
+49 (0) 89 158 90 140
Email
E-Mail anzeigen
Office
Munich
— More news
— Most read in the journal