The 485-x tax incentive programme has met with a muted response in the New York real estate sector. The initiative replaced the previous 421-a programme and was intended to stimulate the creation of affordable housing across the five boroughs. However, the far-reaching wage requirements for construction workers on schemes of 100 residential units or more are proving to be a substantial hurdle for developers, as highlighted by a recent study from the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY).
To avoid the costly regulations that take effect at the 100-unit threshold, an increasing number of developers are designing their schemes just below this limit. Between July 2024 and September 2026, the association recorded a total of 172 building proposals for structures with exactly 99 residential units. Of these, 49 appeared in registration data from the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) for the 485-x programme, whilst 123 applications were submitted as new building filings to the Department of Buildings (DOB).
A historical review shows just how unusual this concentration is: across the entire period from 2008 to 2023, only 13 buildings with exactly 99 units were filed with the Department of Buildings, according to REBNY. In just over two years, this building format has therefore developed into a key vehicle for scheme developments.
Almost a third of registered units in the third quarter of 2026
In the third quarter of 2026, these avoidance manoeuvres reached a provisional peak. During this period, 47 project filings for 99-unit buildings were registered with the DOB. This represents 4,653 homes or 31.6 per cent of the total 14,712 multi-family apartments submitted for approval in the quarter. Nearly a third of the overall development volume was thus positioned precisely at the regulatory threshold.
The regional distribution of applications in the third quarter showed a clear focus on the outer boroughs:
- —18 schemes with 99 units in Brooklyn
- —16 schemes in the Bronx
- —12 schemes in Queens
- —One scheme in Manhattan and no registrations on Staten Island
Criticism of regulatory disincentives
Industry representatives warn of the long-term consequences of this framework for the city's housing shortage. Basha Gerhards, Executive Vice President of Public Policy at REBNY, explained that New York cannot meet its housing needs by deliberately building smaller. Instead, frameworks are required that noticeably enable more housing construction, particularly in well-connected locations capable of supporting higher density. In light of city administration estimates suggesting around 700,000 new homes are required over the coming decade, larger schemes need targeted support so that every borough can contribute to tackling the housing crisis.














