C
olorado’s mountain housing market has shifted from the pandemic‑era seller’s frenzy to a more level playing field. Inventory has climbed to its highest point since before COVID, giving buyers a broader selection and more room for negotiation. As a result, homes are staying on the market longer—single‑family houses in Summit, Park and Lake counties now linger roughly 40 % longer than last year.

    Realtor Dana Cottrell of Summit Resort Group notes that buyers now have “more choice” and are taking the time to compare options. “A condo in Wilderness that offers 1,200 sq ft can command the same price as a studio or one‑bedroom near a ski area,” she says, adding that this comparison process extends decision time.

    Sellers are adjusting expectations. In Steamboat Springs, the average sale price is about 97 % of the listing price, a slight dip from peak demand periods. Coldwell Banker’s Molly Eldridge in Crested Butte reports that buyers are wary of overpaying, prompting sellers to lower prices from earlier summer levels. Contracts are falling through, often due to financing or inspection hurdles, and buyers remain cautious amid global uncertainties.

    Despite the overall slowdown, performance varies by locale and property type. In the Crested‑Butte‑Gunnison corridor, August sales rose 6 % overall but dollar volume fell 5 %. Crested Butte itself saw declines in both metrics, whereas Gunnison experienced gains, with condo and townhome prices jumping 73 %. Gunnison’s affordability—single‑family homes averaging a third of Crested Butte’s price—drives this contrast.

    In Vail, single‑family sales and new listings increased in August, while the townhome/condo segment contracted. Summit County’s single‑family homes dropped 4.9 % in price, yet multifamily units climbed 7.2 %. Steamboat Springs saw a surge in new single‑family listings, but sold inventory lagged, and multifamily units outnumbered last year’s figures.

    Luxury remains a bright spot. In Summit County, homes above $10 million surged 150 % year‑to‑date, and properties between $1.5 million and $2 million rose 79 %. Cash transactions now represent 45 % of all August deals, underscoring strong demand for high‑end properties.

    Mortgage rates have hovered near 7 % for most of the year, which has tempered buyer enthusiasm but also kept the market from a sharp decline. Many buyers are now prioritizing affordability and long‑term value over immediate price drops, leading to more deliberate offers. Sellers, meanwhile, are increasingly transparent about property condition and are offering incentives such as closing‑cost assistance or home‑warranty packages to sweeten deals. The combination of higher inventory, cautious buyers, and strategic seller concessions is shaping a market that is more patient and price‑aware than the frenzy of the pandemic era.

    Overall, the market is characterized by higher inventory, slower sales, and a wider spread of pricing trends that differ by area and property type. Buyers enjoy more options and negotiation power, while sellers must often offer concessions or reduce prices to attract interest. Luxury homes continue to command robust demand, especially in cash‑heavy transactions.