I
n a charming anomaly of uptown Manhattan, Sylvan Terrace stands as a tranquil oasis amidst the bustling streets of Washington Heights. This picturesque row of 20 yellow-painted townhouses, each adorned with pine green shutters and ornate brown cornices, dates back to 1882 when they were developed for working-class residents. The street's grandeur is further enhanced by its proximity to the Morris-Jumel Mansion, Manhattan's oldest surviving residence.

    Sylvan Terrace has long been regarded as one of New York City's most coveted "secret streets," where residents tend to stay put and form close-knit communities. According to sales records, only seven homes have traded hands since 2018, with four of those sales occurring in the past two years. This rarity makes it a prime opportunity for homebuyers or renters seeking a unique and exclusive living experience.

    One of these rare listings is No. 7 Sylvan Terrace, which has been owned by Alexander Scheirle, executive director of the Orpheus Chamber Orchestra, since 2012. The two-bedroom townhouse boasts charming old-world touches, including a mahogany staircase and exposed brick fireplaces. Scheirle has put the property on the market for rent at $6,800 per month.

    Another listing is No. 8 Sylvan Terrace, which recently hit the market with an asking price of $1.82 million. This three-bedroom townhouse features wide-plank wooden floors, wood-beamed ceilings, and several fireplaces. The property's marketing images also highlight its potential for creating a two-family building by renting out the garden level.

    In addition to these listings, No. 18 Sylvan Terrace offers an 850-square-foot one-bedroom rental apartment for $2,750 per month. Whether residents own or rent their homes, they all benefit from the block's strong sense of community. Scheirle recalls holiday parties and summer gatherings, as well as emails circulating among neighbors to retrieve deliveries left on stoops.

    The tight-knit community on Sylvan Terrace is a rare find in New York City, where residents often come and go quickly. As Scheirle notes, "It's just too beautiful and too special, and so many great memories." While he plans to keep his home on the street, one of his neighbors has decided to sell, making it an exciting time for those seeking a unique and exclusive living experience in Manhattan.