A
piece of American history is up for sale on Long Island's Greenlawn, where a circa-1770s timber-frame house built by Revolutionary War soldier Morris Bartow awaits its next chapter. The Dunnes, Laura and Robert, have spent nearly four decades restoring this 18th-century gem, which they've lovingly transformed into a living museum.
The three-bedroom, 3,000-square-foot home boasts original wood floorboards, hand-hewn ceiling beams, and period-appropriate furniture sourced from salvaged materials. The couple added a three-story extension using reclaimed 18th-century bricks and mantels from dismantled New England homes. A walk-in fireplace and bake oven were also built to preserve the colonial charm.
Laura's childhood fascination with early American life fueled their passion for restoration, which brought her dream of cooking on an open hearth to life. The home has attracted descendants of the original occupant and previous residents, who've shared stories and memories within its walls. Locals know the house well, not just for its age but for the rich history it holds.
The property is now listed for $1.24 million, a price that reflects its unique character and historical significance. The Dunnes are selling to retire in New England, where they've purchased another historic home to restore. As they part ways with this beloved piece of American history, they're heartbroken but excited for their next adventure.
The property's listing is being held by William Tarantola of Howard Hanna Coach Realtors, and it stands as one of the priciest listings in the area, where the median home price is $777,000.
