The planned price caps under the government's Your First Home scheme risk being detached from market reality, according to a new evaluation. In around 70 per cent of English local authority districts, average new-build prices are higher than the caps proposed by the state.
Specifically, this discrepancy affects 207 of the 295 administrative districts nationwide, as set out in an analysis by PropertyWire. First-time buyers in these areas are consequently barely able to make use of the government assistance, as corresponding new-build developments are simply priced above the support thresholds.
New-build prices exceed planned caps
The government initiative aims to make it easier for first-time buyers to access home ownership. However, linking the measure to rigid caps leads in practice to a significant regional imbalance. As actual acquisition costs for newly built residential properties exceed the defined limit in many areas, the supply of eligible homes is narrowed drastically.
Particularly in high-demand areas, the support model fails to adequately reflect real price developments. For prospective buyers, acquiring new builds there remains fraught with considerable hurdles, whilst developers in many places are unable to deliver within the mandated price brackets.
Challenges for local support
- —In 207 of a total of 295 English administrative districts, average new-build prices are above the caps.
- —Around 70 per cent of local authorities in England are practically excluded from the measure by the defined criteria.
- —The Your First Home initiative fails in large parts of the country due to regional market conditions.
The evaluation illustrates the fundamental difficulties of designing uniform specifications for heterogeneous housing markets. When more than two thirds of municipal areas are effectively disregarded by the current criteria, the policy initiative falls short of its nationwide objective.
For market participants, the results show that blanket stipulations without regionalised thresholds lead to significant misallocations. Until the caps are adjusted to the actual price levels in the respective districts, first-time buyers across the majority of English regions will remain unable to access this assistance.














