The repercussions of the 2023 US regional banking crisis continue to resonate across the commercial property lending market. At the heart of these developments was New York Community Bank (NYCB), which now trades under the name Flagstar Bank. Unlike institutions such as First Republic Bank or Signature Bank, the bank did not collapse, but plunged into a severe crisis following rapid expansion and rising risk provisioning.
The root causes of the distress lay in two major acquisitions. In 2022, NYCB acquired Flagstar Bank in an all-share transaction valued at $2.6 billion to transform itself from a pure residential construction lender into a broadly diversified commercial bank. Following the collapse of Signature Bank in March 2023, the institution also took over $38.4 billion in assets and all customer deposits. This pushed total assets past the $100 billion threshold, triggering stricter regulatory capital, liquidity, and reporting requirements.
In the fourth quarter of 2023, the bank posted a loss of $2.7 billion. Loan loss provisions were raised by 790 per cent quarter-on-quarter to $552 million to absorb mounting credit risks in the commercial real estate sector. Following the resignation of Chief Executive Thomas Cangemi, an investor consortium led by former US Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin stabilised the institution in March 2024 with a $1 billion capital injection, after which Joseph Otting took over as Chief Executive.
Parallels with the turnaround of IndyMac
In April 2024, Scott Shepherd was appointed head of commercial real estate lending. His mandate is to clean up the loan book and reposition the institution. Strains persisted into 2024: in the second quarter, multifamily arrears rose by 767 per cent, while charge-offs on bad debts increased by 590 per cent. In October 2024, the group completed its rebrand to Flagstar Financial and changed its stock ticker to FLG.
For Shepherd, the remit bears clear parallels to an earlier project. When Mnuchin acquired the failed IndyMac from the FDIC for $13.9 billion in 2009, Otting and Shepherd led the bank's restructuring before it was ultimately sold to CIT as OneWest Bank for $3.4 billion. Shepherd noted that whilst both situations exhibit structural similarities, the starting conditions differ in key respects.
- —As an Alt-A lender, IndyMac focused primarily on distressed single-family residential construction loans and operated without a branch network.
- —Flagstar relies on established customer relationships across the East Coast, the Midwest, and nationwide.
- —A viable branch and private banking network secures Flagstar continuous access to stable deposits.
Shepherd explained that rejoining Otting and Chief Credit Officer Kris Gagnon was a decisive factor in his move. He also highlighted that, despite all criticism, predecessors at Flagstar and NYCB left behind a valuable network of solid borrower relationships upon which future lending can build.














