(
Credit: Reporter file)
Listings for Times Review Media Group, Suffolk Vision Inc., Oct. 3 2025.
SHELTER ISLAND (11964) – 23C West Neck Rd (700‑14‑3‑75.010, R) $1,675,000 (John Sieni → Hugh & Eileen Caulfield)
SHELTER ISLAND Heights (11965) – 9 Tims Trail (700‑18‑1‑5, R) $634,298 (Victoria Weickert → Virginia Weickert & Marc Rocco); 6 Southwick Ln (700‑8‑2‑18, R) $521,667 (Neal Sliker → Leslie & Robert LaRocca)
CUTCHOGUE (11935) – 2100 Duck Pond Rd (1000‑83‑4‑3, R) $1,050,000 (Ronald & Susan Smith → Jack & Nora Mueger); 3000 Pequash Ave (1000‑103‑13‑24, R) $725,000 (Bennie Pawluczyk → NoFo REO LLC)
EAST MARION (11939) – 2400 Bay Ave (1000‑31‑16‑8, R) $1,325,000 (Samuel Cooper & Noushin Najafi → Christopher & Sarah LaMoreaux)
GREENPORT (11944) – 675 Champlin Pl (1000‑34‑3‑30, R) $2,200,000 (Royal & Alison Tuthill → Meghan McDermott); 520 4th St (1001‑6‑2‑16.001, R) $890,000 (Estate of Patricia Pincus → Lukas Pellizzi)
MATTITUCK (11952) – 18600 Main Rd (1000‑115‑6‑3, R) $856,000 (Joseph Casarona → Kristine Gonzalez); 1500 Grand Ave (1000‑107‑3‑13, R) $650,000 (Roberta Alifano → Gregory Olsen)
RIVERHEAD (11901) – 188 Phillips Ln (600‑45‑2‑3.005, R) $2,225,000 (Christopher Seger LLC → Robert & Paula Whitman); 389 Sweezy Ave (600‑123‑4‑33, R) $1,300,000 (Tadeusz Babicz → Patuna LLC); 50 Oakland Dr W (600‑65‑3‑5, R) $500,000 (Pamela Miles → Oakland Drive LLC)
SOUTHOLD (11971) – 1750 Mount Beulah Ave (1000‑51‑3‑2.010, R) $3,850,000 (94 Post Lane LLC → Timothy & Utaukwa Allen); 205 Pine Ave (1000‑77‑2‑29, R) $1,205,000 (Catherine & Timothy Murphy & Maureen & Patrick Murphy → Stephanie & Randy Klopfleisch); 195 Mount Beulah Ave (1000‑51‑2‑8.004, V) $791,000 (Patricia Booth Trust → Mount Beulah LLC); 1700 Smith Dr N (1000‑76‑2‑37.002, V) $450,000 (Emily Schachter → Sea Coast CH Inc)
Key: Tax map = District‑Section‑Block‑Lot; (A)=agriculture; (R)=residential; (V)=vacant; (C)=commercial; (R&E)=recreation & entertainment; (CS)=community services; (I)=industrial; (PS)=public service; (P)=park land; values from current tax rolls.
