realestate

Shelter Island Reporter: Real Estate Transfers – Dec. 5, 2025

Listings for Times Review by Suffolk Vision, Sept. 26, 2025. Island (11964): 65 North Midway Rd to Robert Hansen, $958k.

S
HELF ISLAND (11964)

    65 North Midway Road LLC → Robert Hansen, 65 North Midway Rd (700‑14‑3‑38) (R) $958,000

    Carol Hallman → Scarlett Sunrise LLC, 5 Saint Marys Rd (700‑15‑3‑79) (C) $800,000

    SHELF ISLAND Heights (11965)

    Paul Moschetta → Madeleine Piro, 9 Locust Woods Dr (700‑8‑2‑1.010) (R) $1,200,000

    AQUEBOGUE (11931)

    872 Union Ave LLC → Victor Perez & Veronica Vazquez, 872 Union Ave (600‑66‑4‑1.021) (R) $915,000

    CUTCHOGUE (11935)

    Kevin & Kelly Feeney → Jessica Cosgrove & Karoly Vollmer, 2700 Fairway Dr (1000‑109‑5‑14.013) (R) $1,675,000

    David & Steven Zuhoski → Zuhoski Farms Inc & Zuhoski Family Farms LLC, 12025 Oregon Rd (1000‑83‑2‑13.006) (V) $272,500

    David & Steven Zuhoski → Zuhoski Farms Inc, Oregon Rd (1000‑83‑2‑13.007) (V) $60,000

    ORIENT (11957)

    Dogtrot LLC → Despina & Jay Landers, 1115 Willow Terrace Ln (1000‑26‑2‑30) (V) $799,900

    RIVERHEAD (11901)

    STA Holdings LLC → SXRG Properties LLC, 965 East Main St (600‑131‑1‑1.001) (C) $1,300,000

    Robert Mare → Toni & Brian Neuschaefer, 55 Tyler Dr (600‑64‑1‑6.058) (R) $819,000

    Champion 11 Group LLC → Liliam Baidal, 506 Raynor Ave (600‑123‑1‑8) (R) $595,000

    Cornell Properties Corp → Local Property LLC, 799 Harrison Ave (600‑102‑3‑11) (R) $370,000

    BVR Management Inc → 644 Northville Tpke LLC, 644 Northville Turnpike (600‑106‑3‑6.001) (R) $270,000

    SOUTHOLD (11971)

    Estate of Rosemary Schneider → Jake Vacovec & Gabriella Santi, 8095 Soundview Ave (1000‑59‑6‑16) (R) $1,250,000

    Maria Markakis & Carmen St. George → Jason Bauer & Juan Mangiarotti, 1575 Founders Path (1000‑64‑4‑15) (R) $950,000

    Lucille Vogt → Loretta Braun, 2555 Youngs Ave Apt 12E (1000‑63.02‑1‑37) (R) $602,500

    Daniel & Kimberly Petrie → 1160 Travelers LLC, 1160 Traveler St (1000‑61‑2‑2) (V) $475,000

    Kenneth & David Mueller & Donna Magill → Keith & Donna Magill & Kenneth Mueller, 390 Lake Ave (1000‑80‑4‑4) (R) $200,000

    Key: Tax map = District‑Section‑Block‑Lot; (A)=agriculture, (R)=residential, (V)=vacant, (C)=commercial, (R&E)=recreation & entertainment, (CS)=community services, (I)=industrial, (PS)=public service, (P)=park land.

Shelter Island real estate transfer announcement, December 5, 2025.