Converting disused commercial property into living space is seen by many portfolio holders and investors in the current market environment as an obvious option. In a default judgment dated 19.08.2026 (case ref. VIII ZR 104/25), the Federal Court of Justice clarified the rent law conditions governing such schemes. The judges made clear that a change of use does not automatically result in an exemption from the statutory rent control regulations.
In areas with tight housing markets, Section 556d (1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) stipulates that, in principle, the rent at the start of a tenancy may exceed the local reference rent by no more than 10 per cent. In North Rhine-Westphalia, 57 municipalities are currently subject to this regulatory regime under the NRW Tenant Protection Ordinance. Under Section 556f, sentence 1 of the BGB, a permanent exemption applies only if residential space is first used and let after 1 October 2014. For formerly commercial units, however, supreme court case law sets narrow limits on this new-build exemption.
Objective usability and substantial construction expenditure as core criteria
For the statutory exemption to apply, the premises must, in their previous physical form and fittings, have been objectively unsuitable for residential use. The decisive factor here is prevailing commercial understanding: the space must not previously have constituted an independent, physically and economically demarcated area that would already have permitted the running of an independent household. Rather, its suitability for residential living must first have been created through building works.
In addition, the court requires substantial construction expenditure, guided by Section 16 (1) No. 3 of the Housing Promotion Act (WoFG). As a rule, such expenditure is only deemed substantial if the costs reach around one third of the amount required for a comparable newly built flat, excluding the land value. Mere repair works that simply restore the former condition expressly fail to satisfy these statutory requirements.
Burden of proof and pre-contractual disclosure
The burden of pleading and proving all statutory criteria under Section 556f, sentence 1 of the BGB rests entirely with the landlord. In parallel, Section 556g (1a), sentence 1, No. 3 of the BGB obliges the owner to inform prospective tenants unsolicited, prior to the submission of their contractual declaration, of the initial use and letting after the cut-off date of 1 October 2014.
If this disclosure is omitted, the landlord cannot rely on a permissible rent under Section 556e or Section 556f of the BGB, or may only do so two years after providing it in the required form. Where disclosure was merely formally invalid, reliance on the exemption is possible only after it has been properly provided in the correct form.
As highlighted by Max Reuße, LL.M., of ROTTHEGE Partnerschaftsgesellschaft mbB Rechtsanwälte, Wirtschaftsprüfer, Steuerberater, conversion projects therefore require meticulous preparation. Owners and investors must accurately document the initial physical condition, the specific conversion works and the incurred costs, as well as comply with the pre-contractual disclosure duties under Section 556g of the BGB within the required time and form.














