realestate

Shelter Island Reporter: Real Estate Transfers – Dec. 29, 2025

Times Review, Oct 24, 2025. Shelter Island – Thomas Eagan & Michael Lubin $1.5M; Todd & Melissa Taylor to Todd Taylor.

P
repared by Suffolk Vision Inc. for Times Review Media Group, 24 Oct 2025.

    **SHELTER ISLAND 11964**

    - Myron Zisser Trust → Thomas Eagan & Michael Lubin, 21 Congdon Rd (700‑15‑4‑58) (R) $1,500,000

    - Todd & Melissa Taylor → Todd Taylor, 1 Shorewood Rd (700‑23‑2‑27) (R) $120,000

    **SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS 11965**

    - Ann Loeffler → MWL Ventures LLC, 68A Tuthill Dr (700‑12‑2‑18.002) (R) $700,000

    **AQUEBOGUE 11931**

    - Gary & Deborah Guja → Ashish & Elodie Gupta, 97 Grant Dr (600‑66‑5‑9) (R) $955,000

    **CUTCHOGUE 11935**

    - Susan Ambrosio → Scott Ambrosio, 1940 Mason Dr (1000‑104‑7‑16.001) (R) $597,000

    **EAST MARION 11939**

    - Sefi Graider & Waylon DeCanio → Arnold & Ashley Farber, 410 Aquaview Ave (1000‑21‑3‑4) (R) $1,545,000

    - Jaclyn Costantino & Andrew Charron → Cara McCabe & Christopher Santone, 155 Manor Rd (1000‑38‑4‑5.001) (R) $1,490,000

    **GREENPORT 11944**

    - Marie Mautner → Kamal Helou & Lauren Hartman, 2055 Bay Shore Rd (1000‑53‑4‑12) (R) $2,150,000

    - George & Evangela Georgaklis → Amir Hariri & Kimberly Desmarais, 795 Westwood Ln (1000‑33‑2‑7) (R) $1,230,000

    - Mary Gabriel & Adrianne Greenberg → Kristie Waller, 43 Sound Rd (1000‑33‑4‑74) (R) $800,000

    - Estate of Ellen Wiederlight → 326 Front St Properties LLC, 220 Fourth Ave (1001‑4‑8‑28) (V) $400,000

    **JAMESPORT 11947**

    - Mary Rasor → Gaurav Hingorani & Colette Beckett, 174 Manor Ln (600‑47‑2‑11) (R) $927,500

    - Joseph & Laurie LoRusso → Alvaro Palencia & Angelica Sandoval, 276 Herricks Ln (600‑23‑1‑12.004) (R) $875,000

    - Raymond & Darrell Janis → 1505 Main Rd LLC, 1505 Main Rd (600‑68‑4‑58.001) (V) $400,000

    **LAUREL 11948**

    - Gregory Olsen → John & Mary Jeffrey, 6645 Peconic Bay Blvd (1000‑126‑10‑20) (R) $1,100,000

    **MATTITUCK 11952**

    - Thomas & Rosemary McDermott Trust → Nicole & Stephen O’Grady, 315 Old Salt Rd (1000‑144‑5‑20) (R) $1,750,000

    - Tyler Land Corp → BKDK Main Rd LLC, 6795 Main Rd (1000‑125‑1‑19.006) (C) $1,500,000

    - Melvarene Stephens → Candee Ulmet & Filiz Reed, 2650 Wickham Ave (1000‑139‑3‑7) (R) $1,205,000

    - Gloria Onufrak → 5100 Cox Lane Corp, 1500 Marys Rd (1000‑114‑5‑1.002) (R) $995,000

    - Nancy & David Reeve → Jill & Mark DeSantis, 1235 New Suffolk Ave (1000‑114‑11‑25) (R) $660,000

    - Gloria Onufrak → Edward & Nickie Danowski, 1500 Marys Rd (1000‑114‑5‑1.002) (V) $555,500

    **ORIENT 11957**

    - 1885 Green LLC → John & Barbara Parisi, 1855 Greenway East (1000‑15‑1‑10) (R) $1,775,000

    **SOUTH JAMESPORT 11970**

    - Robert Sosik → Louis & Diane Ventura, 57 Front St (600‑92‑4‑6) (R) $730,000

    **SOUTHOLD 11971**

    - Christopher & Colleen Connors → George & Olga Themelis, 350 West Dr (1000‑59‑5‑29.003) (R) $1,240,000

    *Tax map: District‑Section‑Block‑Lot; (R)=residential, (V)=vacant, (C)=commercial.*

Shelter Island real estate transfer: signed contract and handshake, Dec. 29, 2025.