A
newly established historic district in St. Petersburg's Mirror Lake neighborhood is facing a legal challenge from real estate attorney Matt Weidner, who claims the designation violates a 2023 state law prohibiting referendums on land development regulations. The city council approved the district with a 5-2 vote last week, sparking divisions within the community over preservation and development. The district includes Mirror Lake Park and surrounding properties, excluding the Sunshine Center to allow for potential redevelopment.

    Weidner's lawsuit also questions the quasi-judicial process used by the city council, arguing it is unconstitutional. Critics of the district fear it will stifle development, citing concerns that similar referendums could block projects in other parts of the city. The designation imposes restrictions on property owners, requiring approval for significant changes or demolitions.

    Dissenting council members criticized the ordinance as overly burdensome and questioned the arbitrary boundaries of the district. Urban Planning Manager Derek Kilborn defended the district, citing parallels with historic designations in neighborhoods like Historic Kenwood. A hearing was held last week, with a decision expected in January.