In his book 'The Imperfect City: Design, Serendipity, and the Real Life of Cities', published by Knopf, Pulitzer Prize-winning architecture critic Paul Goldberger analyses the success factors of major metropolises. In his view, the most resilient cities emerge where a dynamic balance exists between public planning and free private development. In an interview with trade journal Commercial Observer, Goldberger discussed how this tension continues to shape New York City to this day.
The tension between regulation and market forces
Goldberger explained that cities planned down to the very last square foot often fail in practice or lose their vitality. However, an entirely unregulated approach leads to dysfunctional conditions. Neither urban planners nor private developers alone can guarantee a functioning urban fabric. New York's urban quality stems instead from the continuous negotiation process between both sides. Absolute perfection makes cities rigid, whereas controlled imperfection provides room for organic evolution.
Infrastructure and the Manhattan grid as a foundation
Regarding New York's historical development, Goldberger highlighted two milestones: the construction of the Erie Canal and the street grid plan of 1811. The canal created a direct link between the Midwest and the Atlantic, turning New York into an indispensable hub for freight handling and subsequently into the leading financial centre. At the same time, the orthogonal grid system across Manhattan laid the foundation for the efficient commercialisation of plots.
The uniform blocks made it easy to demarcate and trade plots of comparable value, accelerating the perception of property as standardised economic assets. The distinguishing feature of the grid was that in 1811 it boldly extended up to 155th Street, yet imposed hardly any functional restrictions on use for over a century. Only with the subsequent introduction of zoning regulations did clearer boundaries for architectural use emerge.
Looking at today's property market, Goldberger called for a greater sense of responsibility from public authorities. Large-scale developments are currently heavily driven by international investment capital, which is often primarily focused on returns per square foot and neglects the urban context. The trend towards ever larger buildings therefore requires more decisive intervention from urban planning to secure the balance within the urban space over the long term.














